Here's an interesting tidbit that I missed last week. The
Australian Press Council upheld a complaint by a reader of
the Sydney Morning Herald who felt that a cartoon by Alan
Moir was racist and should not have been published. (Although
Alan is a regular on our site, we didn't receive a copy of the
offending cartoon.)
The Herald acknowledged a "lapse in judgement" in printing
the August 12th cartoon which juxtaposed images of the Warsaw
Ghetto and the security wall being built on Israel's West Bank.
The cartoon showed two images of roads blocked by walls, with
a wall labeled "Warsaw 1943" and a wall labeled "West
Bank 2003." The Herald printed many angry responses from
readers in addition to an unusual apology by the Herald's editor.
The cartoon above is by Jordanian cartoonist Emad
Hajjaj from the Ad-Dustour newspaper in Amman. This image
features a typical theme for Arab cartoonists who love to compare
Israel to Nazi Germany and compare Palestinians to Holocaust
victims.
What we might consider shocking, racist, anti-Semitic images
are accepted, everyday fare in Arab countries. What is commonplace
and banal imagery in the Middle East is the stuff of scandal
in the West --a recurring scandal, as a similar cartoon seems
to pop up and horrify readers of a different, mainstream, Western
newspaper every couple of months.
November 16, 2003
As the cartoonist-editor of this big cartoon site, I'm often
asked where I see editorial cartoons going in the future, with
new technology. Usually I'm asked by a journalist who expects
me to answer by saying that cartoonists will all be doing animation
and taking advantage of the web's hi-tech bells and whistles.
I don't see that happening, at least not any time soon.
There are a handful of guys doing
nice animated editorial cartoons, Forever
Dada's Dunn and Campbell and Mark
Fiore draw a new animated cartoon every week. Don
Assmussen does two or three a year. But there is little or
no business incentive to create animated web cartoons. Web sites
rarely commission original content. Editorial cartoons continue
to be drawn for a print audience.
Before the web bubble burst, there were lots of guys doing great
animation work for the web. Almost all of them stopped when the
dot-coms crashed. The web has turned into an efficient redistribution
network for content created by other media --as you see on this
site. There has never been a resource like our site before. To
see the work of the worlds editorial cartoonists as soon as the
cartoons are published is pretty cool, and the web makes that
possible --but the cartoons are still newspaper cartoons.
Looking back three
or four years, before the crash, when the dot-coms were flush
with money, it seemed like a Renaissance for editorial cartoonists.
Bill Mitchell was doing great animated editorial cartoons for
CNN. My favorite animated editorial cartoonist was Mike Lester,
who drew a daily, animated cartoon for Dow Jones-Work.com. The
crash brought Mike's web animation career to an end, before a
large audience could see his innovative work. Unlike the other
cartoonists who made Flash animations, Mike made small, simple
animated gifs that told short stories, with clever timing and
a cast of characters that regular readers could get to know.
Mike had a long career as a top advertising illustrator, but
editorial cartooning is addictive --even a short stint as an
political cartoonist will get a cartoonist hooked. About a year
ago, Mike went to work as a daily editorial cartoonist for his
home-town Rome (Georgia) News-Tribune. We often grouse about
the loss of jobs in our profession but the Rome News-Tribune
created a new position for Mike. It is unusual for cartoonists
to become editorial cartoonists after working in other areas
of cartooning. Editorial cartoonists usually start out by drawing
for their school newspapers, and start working for newspapers
right out of college. I think Mike's background in advertising
gives him a different look and a different perspective than his
editorial cartoonist peers --and he is naturally funny in a way
that is, again, different.
I regret that Mike isn't doing the animated cartoons anymore,
but I'm delighted to have him on our site as a print editorial
cartoonist. Mike is an instant star as an editorial cartoonist;
his cartoons are syndicated to hundreds of papers across the
country.
That's the trend I see. Forget the animation. Draw for print.
Make a living. And if you give a cartoonist an opportunity to
draw editorial cartoons, he'll never want to do anything else.
November 15, 2003
I found this
interesting article at Forbes.com about cartoonist/illustrator
Frank Frazetta (thanks to the excellent Comics
Journal blog). I thought Frank Frazetta's work was fantastic
in the 1970's, when I was growing up. He seemed to be everywhere.
Then he seemed to disappear, and I wondered what happened to
him. His work didn't disappear, though, as his paintings still
influence comic book artists and can be seen everywhere at any
comics convention. There is a new
Frank Frazetta Museum in East Stroudsburg, PA.
Frazetta is known throughout comicdom as the cartoonist/artist
whose work commands the highest prices. The Forbes.com article
included this list of the highest prices at auction for the work
of American illustrators ...
Frederic
Remington, "A Reconnaissance"
$ 5,200,000
Norman
Rockwell, "Rosie the Riveter"
$ 4,960,000
Maxfield
Parrish
$4,300,000
N.C.
Wyeth
$ 660,000
Jessie
Willcox Smith
$ 150,000
Ludwig
Bemelmans
$ 140,000
Frank
Frazetta
$ 120,000
Howard
Pyle
$ 120,000
Harvey
Dunn
$ 110,000
November
9, 2003
Sorry, I missed a few days. I
was busy with other stuff. Don't worry, nothing happened on any
of those days.
Steve Kelley
is one of my favorite cartoonists. Steve hasn't been on the site
for a long time. He was one of our regulars until he was fired
from the San Diego Union Tribune in a rather lively spat that
grew out of the cartoon at the right. Steve's editor objected
to the butt cracks and killed the cartoon. This led to that and
Steve was fired. The Union Tribune quickly hired Steve
Breen to replace Steve Kelley.
Kelley landed on his feet at the New Orleans Times Picayune,
whose cartoonist, Walt
Handelsman had left to take the spot at Newsday in New York,
where their cartoonist, Doug
Marlette had been fired, but then moved to Tallahassee. Keep
up, there will be a test at the end.
As in every game of musical chairs, each time the players move,
a seat is lost. In this case, the Asbury Park Press, which lost
their cartoonist Steve Breen, decided they didn't need a cartoonist
anymore. Breen had brought a Pulitzer Prize to this mid-sized
New Jersey newspaper, but that wasn't enough to show the newspaper's
editors the value of a staff cartoonist.
The important thing to remember is that, if not for butt cracks,
Steve Kelley might still be in San Diego, and he would never
have left our site. We missed Steve Kelley, we're happy to have
him back, and we love butt cracks, here at the Cartoonists Index.
November 8, 2003
I watched ABC's 20/20 last night, where Barbara Walters interviewed
Martha Stewart. Barbara asked if the public criticism bothered
Martha, and noted the harsh depictions in a CBS made-for-TV movie
and on Saturday Night Live. Martha replied that none of that
bothered her, but what really got to her was the editorial cartoons.
20/20 then went on to show cartoons that were lifted from our
Martha Stewart collections without permission or attribution,
by John Cole, Ken Catalino and Clay Jones. I can understand why
the editorial cartoons really bother Martha. They bother me too,
when they are shown without permission or attribution.
The lead item on our site this
week was a column by Michael
Reagan and cartoons on CBS's cancellation of the Reagan movie.
This created an interesting contrast with the lead article on
Slate titled, "Saint
Ronald," by Chatterbox author Timothy Noah, who castigated
CBS for cancelling the movie. Noah followed up the next day with
another Reagan bashing article, "Saint
Ronald Part 2." Point/Counterpoint, huh? The editors
at Slate are very nice about giving me editorial freedom,
although the front page contrast is seldom so obvious.
My e-mailbox is usually filled
with venom from conservatives bashing me as a "liberal cartoonist,"
and "just what (they) would expect from that liberal rag,
Slate." The Reagan article and cartoons turned my
e-mail box around by 180 degrees. Now I'm derided as a conservative.
Here is an example:
Daryl, PLEASE,
We all get that you are a right-winger and a Republican, but
can you just put up the cartoons? The commentary by Mike Reagan
was over the top even if you thought it was "just putting
everything in context." It was an unwelcome addition. I
like that you put up cartoons that knock the left right and center
the celebs and the working stiffs alike, but your personal political
views do you a disfavor by tainting the quality of the cartoonists
with unnecessary context. We are all adults. We can read for
ourselves
Ty Sherrif,Chicago
November 6, 2003
Today I tried something new.
I posted a column by Presidential son and Talk Radio host, Michael
Reagan, about CBS cancelling the Reagan movie --and I posted
it at the top of the front page, rather than here in the BLOG
where words usually reside on this cartoon site. Cartoons are
usually used as art to spice up a page full of words. I'd like
to see words used to compliment an article full of cartoons.
Cartoonists have always felt that their graphic opinions predominate
over the "sea of text" surrounding their images on
the page; I wonder how the equation works out when the words
illustrate the cartoons. Take
a look at the "article" and let
me know what you think. Should we include words with our
cartoons?
November
2, 2003
NIK KOWSAR'S STORY
Iranian cartoonist, Nik Kowsar, is a long time contributor to
our site. See
Nik's cartoons here. Visit
Nik's site here. E-mail
Nik here. Nik's life has been threatened by Islamic militant
hardliners in Iran. Nik wrote to us to tell his story ...
Years ago, when I was a Geology
student at Tehran University, I started drawing caricatures of
my professors. The result was failing grades! After a few months,
I was working as a professional cartoonist and I became a threat
to my professors. Once, one of them gave me some useful advice.
He said: "Don't forget! We are living in a country where
no one tolerates criticism. In Iran, we know critics as harmful
people who only humiliate." I paid no attention to his advice.
Eight years later, I drew a cartoon
that didn't have anything to do with any particular cleric or
official and I was threatened by the hardliners. A large gathering
of clergy students in the holy city of Qum called for my death.
They believed that I had made fun of a famous cleric, Ayatullah
Mesbah-e Yazdi.
In a cartoon, I had drawn a crocodile
that was killing a journalist, and crying crocodile tears, pretending
to be hurt by the poor journalist (who I drew as my "Sick
Nick" character). I had named the crocodile in this cartoon,
"Ostad Temsah" (Professor Crocodile). Unfortunately,
the names of crocodile and the cleric rhymed. My newspaper, voluntarily
stopped publishing for a week. I was arrested and sent to prison
on February 6th, 2000.
This
wasn't the first time that a cartoonist was imprisoned in Iran,
but my imprisonment was big news, coming just before the parliamentary
elections. Almost everyone in Iran took notice of my arrest.
I was lucky because I was treated well in prison, unlike other
journalists who were sent to prison after me.
I was free on bail after six
days, and I got permission to draw again ten days later. This
was a terrible experience for me and for my family, and it was
a great burden for a guy who had only tried to draw funny pictures.
I then had to prove that I was
innocent to the people who hated me. My mother, who lives in
another city, received threatening letters, from hardliners who
threatened to kill me.
Thirteen months later I wrote
a letter to the famous cleric whose name rhymed with the name
of the character in my cartoon. In the letter, I wrote that I
didn't mean to be disrespectful and that I only wanted to draw
a simple cartoon for my audience. I wrote: "Your Excellency,
if you or any of your followers have been harmed and humiliated
by my cartoon, I really feel sorry, and I apologize." I
sent it by fax and I received an answer ten minutes later. The
cleric had accepted my apology and he asked me to pay more attention
next time. I thought all of my troubles had gone away, but in
a few weeks, the judge, now famous for the Zahra Kazemi case
(The Iranian-Canadian photo journalist who was killed in the
same prison where I had been held) ordered me to appear before
him in court.
I felt tremendous stress after
I received this summons. I even had to stay at the intensive
care unit of the hospital because of my heart problems. Since
drawing the crocodile cartoon I have felt like there was a sword
of Damocles hanging above my head.
Whenever
another Iranian cartoonist would draw a cartoon that was pushing
on the bounds of what was acceptable, I was scared, because everyone
thought I was the one who drew every cartoon like that.
I then received a threatening
letter. telling me that my name was on a "death list."
A group of hardliners who live in the shadows, and who have killed
writers and intellectuals in the past, had threatened me with
death. A friend told me that there was a plan in the works for
the courts to arrest a few journalists again, and that my name
was also on a new list of people to be arrested.
Thank God that I was invited
by the Association
of Canadian Editorial Cartoonists (ACEC) to attend their
convention. The ACEC helped to exhibit my anti-war cartoons in
Canada. My journalist colleagues had been arrested, and I would
have been too, if I had not been away in Canada.
A week ago, I received yet another
death threat. My name had appeared just below the name of the
2003 Nobel Peace Prize winner, Shirin Ebadi, on an assassination
list issued by the same militant Islamic group that had threatened
me before. Iranian President Khatami's brother is also on this
list.
The group posting the newest
death threats hasn't executed anyone since the late 90's, but
some speculate that their credibility may be at stake now. A
recently concluded agreement with United Nations nuclear site
inspectors has infuriated hardliners who see the agreement as
a threat to their influence. The hardliners have threatened to
kill the people on their list for the good of Islam, wherever
in world they find them.
Now my family blames me for all
the problems they face. I just wanted to be a good cartoonist.
That's all.
November 1, 2003
My e-buddy, Olle Johansson, just won
the big prize for cartoonists in Sweden, the Swedish Newspaper
Association's "Newspaper Profile of the Year" award,
which comes with a nifty ten thousand Kroner prize. What a deal!
Congratulations to Olle! You can see Olle's handsome smile at
the right, and see
his cartoons by clicking here.
I just heard that Nick Armington
died. Cartoonists know Nick as a regular visitor to our National
Cartoonists Society conventions where Nick was filming a documentary
for PBS about the comics. Although he wasn't a cartoonist, Nick
had a passion for cartoons. He got to know all of us, and he
eagerly filmed interviews with us. Nick died while scuba diving
off of California's Channel Islands at the age of 41. He was
a great friend of the cartoonists and we will miss him. Click
here to read a story from the scuba diving site, CDNN. Click
here to visit Nick's film company site, "Alchemedia."